Home - Knowledge - Details

Why Chlorinated Paraffins are Being Phased Out? Everything the Lubricant Industry Needs to Know

Chlorinated paraffins (CPs) were a common chlorine-based extreme-pressure additive in metalworking fluids and lubricants. For difficult-to-machine materials (e.g., stainless steel, titanium alloys),It is still relied upon by many formulators for its EP performance.


1. What are Chlorinated Paraffins? Where are They Used?
 

Chlorinated paraffins are products obtained by the chlorination of n-alkanes. Based on the carbon chain length of the raw materials, it's categorized into Short-Chain (C10-C13), Medium-Chain (C14-C17), and Long-Chain (C18+). In China, commercial CP mainly has two chlorine content levels: 42% and 52%.

Globally, the application distribution is roughly: PVC Auxiliary Plasticizers: 45%;Lubricant Additives: 25% ;Fire-resistant and Anti-corrosive Coatings: 13% ;Flame Retardants: 10% and
Others (Textile/Paper treatment): 7% .

EP Mechanism: In lubricants and metalworking fluids (MWFs), CPs react with metal surfaces at high temperatures to form layered protective films such as FeCl₂ and FeCl₃,These films have low melting points and are easily sheared, thereby reducing wear.
polymeric esters

2. Chlorinated Paraffins in Lubricants: Once the Standard
 

Historically, CPs were concentrated in two main areas:

Automotive Gear Oils:
CPs were standard components in sulfur-phosphorus-chlorine-zinc type hypoid gear oils. However, their use has significantly decreased in modern formulations. In the US and Western Europe, organic chlorides are no longer used in automotive gear oils.

Metalworking Fluids (MWFs):
This remains the largest application area. Addition levels are typically between 1%–5%. It is still relied upon by many formulators for its EP performance when working with difficult-to-machine metals like stainless steel and titanium alloys.

3. Why Must Chlorinated Paraffins Be Phased Out?

The issues with CPs are not about performance but environmental and safety concerns.
1. Hydrolytic Corrosion Issues: CPs generate free HCl upon contact with water, corroding metal equipment and workpieces. This makes CPs a "time bomb" in water-cooled metalworking scenarios.

2. Dioxin Formation During Incineration: When waste fluids containing chlorine-based EP agents are incinerated at insufficient temperatures, they can produce highly carcinogenic dioxins, often called the "poison of the century." Dioxins can cause extensive damage to both the environment and aquatic ecosystems.

3. Limited Effective Temperature Range: The protective iron chloride film formed by CP has a load-bearing temperature of about 350°C, much lower than the 1193°C of iron sulfide formed by sulfur-based additives.This makes CP inadequate for high-speed, high-load conditions.
 

Tightening International Regulations: In December 2022, China approved amendments to the Stockholm Convention, officially listing SCCPs as Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs). This mandates strict control over their production and use. EU REACH regulations previously identified SCCPs as one of 16 high-risk substances toxic to humans and the environment; MCCPs are also facing strict restrictions.

4. Alternative Solutions: Sulfur-based EP Agents and Polymeric Esters

Sulfur-based Extreme Pressure Agents

Sulfurized Isobutylene (T321) is currently the most mature alternative. With a sulfur content of 40%–46%, it reacts to form an FeS protective film with a melting point of 1193°C. It offers excellent hydrolytic stability and maintains lubrication up to 800°C. Compared to CPs, sulfur-based agents provide superior load-carrying performance at similar reactivity levels. T321 has completely replaced chlorinated formulas in automotive and industrial gear oils.
 

Chours' T2540 is a type of antiwear EP additive with a high content of active sulfur. It can be used for various metal processing oils, gear oils, and greases, especially recommended for turning, drilling, grinding, tapping, etc. Please contact us.

Polymeric Esters

These are high molecular weight ester compounds synthesized with a pentaerythritol skeleton. They feature molecular weights up to 25,000, viscosity indices of 200–260, and thermal weight loss temperatures of 450–475°C.
 

Performance: In emulsified cutting fluids, a formula with 5% polymeric ester achieved a tapping efficiency of 120% on 6061 aluminum alloy, comparable or superior to a formula containing 10% sulfurized lard + 4% CP (119%).
 

Advantages: Chlorine-free, sulfur-free, and biodegradable. Its mechanism relies on fluid lubrication provided by a high-viscosity oil film rather than chemical adsorption.
 

Chorus offers a variety of polymeric esters suitable for gear oils and MWFs, with performance comparable to international brands. Please contact us for consultation.

5. Recommendations for Use

For metalworking fluid formulations currently using CPs, the following transition priorities are suggested:
 

Automotive & Industrial Gear Oils: Use Sulfurized Isobutylene; this is a proven, industrialized solution.
 

MWFs (Light to Medium Duty): Use polymeric esters to fully replace CPs. Combining them with overbased sulfonates can further enhance EP effects.

MWFs (Heavy Duty/Difficult Materials): Adopt a "Polymeric Ester + Sulfur-based EP Agent" hybrid approach to balance environmental compliance with performance.
 

Export Products: If the target market is the EU or North America, chlorinated paraffins must be removed to avoid compliance risks.
 

Chorus can supply various polymeric esters for automotive gear oils and metalworking fluids according to customer needs. Our products' performance is comparable to that of international brands. Please feel free to contact us for consultation.

Send Inquiry

You Might Also Like

CC2831C1E7691A119C94D0C59807A144